Here's what you need: 2 slices of bread, peanut butter, jam
Here's what you do: cut a jack-o-lantern face out of the middle of 1 slice of bread. Prepare a peanut butter and jam sandwich with the jack-o-lantern face on top. Then, cut the sandwich into a circle with a circle cookie cutter or a mason jar lid (to seal the edges).
Alternatives: for allergies use soy butter (yum). But if you have no peanut allergies and haven't tried JIF's peanut butter and honey you'll have to give it a try - so good! Use any kind of jam/jelly preferred (I know kids can be picky). I used home-made apricot for the orange effect.